As Croatia works to clean up around 44,000 tonnes of illegally dumped waste in Gospić, Bosnia and Herzegovina (BiH) awaits a European Commission decision on whether it will be allowed to continue receiving paper, waste tyres, RDF and textiles from the EU after May 2027. An investigation shows that BiH demonstrated its capacity largely through facility permits rather than quantities treated, did not analyse how much domestic waste could replace imports, and lacks linked customs and entity-level information systems capable of tracking the same shipment through to final treatment.
Although some domestic media outlets previously reported that BiH had applied for permission to continue importing waste from the EU, a far more important development went almost unnoticed: on 18 September, in its draft initial list, the European Commission provisionally gave BiH the green light to continue importing paper, waste tyres, RDF and textiles after May 2027, despite identifying serious shortcomings in the country’s waste management system in the same assessment!
On 21 February 2025, BiH applied for permission to continue importing six categories of waste from the EU once the new regime takes effect: ferrous and non-ferrous metal scrap, paper, waste tyres, RDF, or refuse-derived fuel, and textile waste. The European Commission subsequently requested further clarification and data on two occasions, which BiH supplied in October 2025 and January 2026.
On 18 September, the Commission published a draft initial list of non-OECD countries that would be permitted to continue receiving certain types of non-hazardous waste from the EU after May 2027. BiH provisionally received the green light for paper, waste tyres, RDF and textiles, while metal scrap did not pass the assessment. Unlike the other approved waste streams, RDF will require prior notification and consent.
Neighbouring Serbia also received a positive assessment in the same draft for all three waste streams it had applied for – paper, waste tyres and metal scrap.
The new European rules were introduced precisely on the grounds that the EU must no longer export its own waste problems to countries that lack the capacity to manage waste in an environmentally sound manner. Exports of plastic waste to non-OECD countries will be banned from 21 November 2026, while a new regime will apply to other covered types of non-hazardous waste from 21 May 2027: exports will be permitted only to countries and for waste streams approved in advance by the European Commission.
The first such list must be adopted by 21 November this year. Right now, with virtually no wider public debate in BiH, decisions are being made on whether the country will remain a destination for some of Europe’s waste in the coming years, and under what conditions!
As that decision approaches, the responses from institutions and companies gathered by Gerila raise a question far more important than formal permission to import: can BiH establish not only that a lorry carrying waste crossed the border legally, but also where that waste ended up and what was done with it?
Gospić: A Warning of What Happens When Paperwork No Longer Reflects Reality
The Gospić case shows why waste controls do not end at the border and why paperwork in order is not, in itself, a guarantee that a shipment will reach its declared destination.
In early 2025, USKOK, Croatia’s Office for the Suppression of Corruption and Organised Crime, launched an investigation into suspected organised imports of shredded plastic and other mixed waste from Slovenia and Italy between early 2022 and the end of September 2024, alongside deliveries of medical and other mixed waste from within Croatia. Investigators suspect that, instead of being properly treated, some of the waste was buried or covered with soil and gravel at sites in Gospić, Varaždin and Benkovac.
The investigation, however, is not focused solely on what happened to the waste after it reached its destination. USKOK also suspects that false documents were drawn up concerning the procurement, transport and movement of waste, that inspectors were supplied with false data, and that information entered in official records did not reflect what was happening on the ground.
By October 2026, the investigation had expanded further. USKOK now also suspects unlawful waste handling dating back to 2020. One part of the investigation describes at least 330 waste transfer notes listing Gospić as the delivery location, although investigators suspect that the waste ended up in Benkovac.
Based on investigators’ suspicions so far, the problem was not necessarily limited to illegal border crossings. Waste could enter a formally regulated system, with a sender, a recipient and accompanying documentation, only for the link between the paperwork and what actually happened to the waste to be lost later.
Croatia now estimates that around 44,000 tonnes of hazardous and non-hazardous waste require remediation at the former PPK Velebit site in Gospić alone. Almost 33,000 tonnes are buried and mixed with soil and stone, around 4,500 tonnes of hazardous waste lie scattered beside a silo, and the remaining quantities are in bags, buildings and the silo. The estimated cost of removing just the 4,500 tonnes of scattered hazardous waste, which will be incinerated outside Croatia, is around EUR 8.8 million.
The consequences went beyond suspicions of unlawful business practices. During 2026, PFAS, known as ‘forever chemicals’, were found in both the waste and groundwater immediately adjacent to the illegal dump, with the same compounds detected in both. At the same time, testing of the public water supply did not detect PFAS above the limit of quantification, so, at least for now, there are no grounds for claiming that drinking water in Gospić is contaminated with these compounds.
Professor Gordana Medunić of the University of Zagreb’s Faculty of Science warns that removing waste from an illegal dump does not mean its consequences have also been eliminated.
‘Removing illegally dumped waste does not solve the problem once and for all,’ Medunić says, noting that only laboratory analyses and monitoring of soil and water can establish whether pollutants have already entered the environment.
Karst terrain, on which Gospić and large parts of Croatia and BiH lie, poses a particular problem. Medunić explains that toxic substances can spread through fissures, sinkholes and underground channels at speeds ranging from tens to hundreds of metres per hour. Unlike other types of terrain, where soil layers can partially filter out pollutants, karst allows them to reach underground aquifers rapidly and directly. The paths of these underground flows are difficult to predict precisely, making remediation after contamination extremely complex.
This is where the Gospić case connects directly with the issue of transboundary waste shipments to BiH. It is not enough to know that a shipment crossed the border legally and was accompanied by the required documentation. What matters is knowing where it ended up and what happened to it after it entered the country.
The responses we received from institutions during this investigation show that BiH still lacks a unified electronic system that would automatically track a shipment from customs clearance through to receipt and final treatment.
BiH Presented Its Permitted Capacity to the Commission, but Not How Much Waste It Can Actually Treat
The FBiH Ministry of Environment and Tourism (MET FBIH) confirmed to us that it participated in preparing Bosnia and Herzegovina’s application to the European Commission to remain among the countries permitted to import certain types of non-hazardous waste from the EU after the new regime takes effect on 21 May 2027.
Following notification from the Ministry of Foreign Trade and Economic Relations of BiH (MoFTER), which coordinated the entire process, the FBiH Ministry asked businesses in the Federation of BiH in December 2024 to provide valid environmental and waste management permits, along with data on the quantities of non-hazardous waste they had imported from EU member states during 2023.
Although MoFTER served as the central institution coordinating the application to the European Commission, it had not answered our questions by the time this article was finalised. It was therefore one of the few competent authorities from which we received no clarification on the data BiH used to assess its capacity, how it consolidated information from the entities and Brčko District, or how it substantiated to the Commission the country’s ability to manage the waste streams covered by its application.
The data received were then incorporated into the documentation BiH submitted to the European Commission as evidence that it had the appropriate facilities, permits and capacity to receive and treat the waste it sought to continue importing.
For paper waste, the documentation listed Natron Hayat in Maglaj, among others, based on the capacity specified in its valid permits. The FBiH Ministry of Environment and Tourism warns, however, that this permitted capacity cannot automatically be interpreted as the quantity of imported paper waste the facility can receive and treat.
For RDF/SRF, fuel derived from waste and used as an alternative fuel in the cement industry, the documentation listed two cement plants: Lukavac Cement and Heidelberg Materials Cement BiH in Kakanj. In its response, however, the Ministry did not specify a single annual capacity figure for these plants relevant to the application, explaining that a distinction must be made between permitted capacity, a cement plant’s production capacity and the actual quantities handled annually.
The situation with textiles is even more striking: MET FBIH states that, according to the official records used to respond to the Commission, there were no facilities in the Federation of BiH specifically authorised to treat textile waste.
The competent ministry in the Republika Srpska also highlighted the difference between permitted and actual capacity.
The RS Ministry of Spatial Planning, Construction and Ecology confirmed that data from waste management permits issued in the Republika Srpska were also submitted to the European Commission as part of BiH’s application. However, the Ministry stresses that the capacities stated in these documents represent permitted capacities established by individual administrative decisions, rather than the Ministry’s assessment of facilities’ actual capacities or data on the quantities of waste treated.
This is one of the key distinctions also highlighted by Professor Dušica Pešević of the University of Banja Luka’s Faculty of Natural Sciences and Mathematics.
‘Permitted capacity provides a regulatory framework but does not in itself prove that a facility can, at any given time, safely and effectively treat the full permitted quantity of waste,’ Pešević says.
According to her, checks must cover actual annual treatment volumes, the technical condition of equipment, emissions monitoring, quantities already contracted, remaining available capacity and, an often-overlooked element, how residues generated by treatment are managed.
Precisely this kind of comprehensive analysis was not carried out when BiH applied for permission to continue importing waste.
MET FBIH states that the documentation used for the application to the European Commission contains no separate quantified analysis showing how much domestic waste with the appropriate characteristics is available and to what extent it could replace imported material.
The Ministry therefore explicitly states that, based on the application, ‘it cannot claim’ that domestic waste has been shown to be unable to replace some imports.
Nor was a separate analysis conducted in the Republika Srpska for each waste type to establish the extent to which domestic quantities could replace imports.
This is particularly important because BiH simultaneously invokes the use of waste as a resource, while much of its domestic waste still goes to landfill instead of being separated, recycled or prepared for reuse.
According to the data MET FBIH used in the European questionnaire, public waste collection services collected 598,446 tonnes of municipal waste in the Federation of BiH during 2023, while as much as 562,019 tonnes were permanently disposed of at registered landfill sites. Only 15,087 tonnes were collected separately, and official data from the FBiH Institute for Statistics on the annual quantities of waste recycled were unavailable.
Professor Pešević therefore does not believe that all waste imports should automatically be viewed negatively. Certain types of waste can be valuable secondary raw materials if a demonstrably safe technological process is in place. The problem arises, Professor Pešević explains, when industry finds it easier to import material that has already been prepared than to invest in a system that would separate, clean and prepare domestic waste for reuse.
‘Imports must not become a substitute for developing a domestic waste management system,’ she says.
Tens of Thousands of Tonnes of RDF Are Already Entering BiH
RDF and SRF best illustrate the economics behind the story.
RDF (Refuse-Derived Fuel) is fuel produced by processing non-hazardous waste, usually by sorting, shredding and removing unsuitable fractions. SRF (Solid Recovered Fuel) is a more strictly defined and standardised type of such fuel. Its quality is determined by parameters such as calorific value and chlorine and mercury content, allowing it to be used in industrial facilities, primarily cement plants.
Data supplied to us by the Indirect Taxation Authority of BiH (ITA BiH) show that approximately 57,503 tonnes were imported in 2024, 64,138 tonnes in 2025 and 40,951 tonnes so far in 2026 from Italy, Slovenia, Croatia and Austria under the tariff code used to declare this alternative fuel.
Most of it ends up at two cement plants.
Lukavac Cement says it imported 55,227 tonnes of RDF/SRF in 2024, 59,601 tonnes the following year and 38,613 tonnes in the first nine months of this year. More than 80 per cent comes from Slovenia, with a further ten to 15 per cent from Croatia.
Only small trial quantities – a few hundred tonnes a year – come from BiH, the company says. It attributes this to the almost complete absence of infrastructure for the separate collection and processing of domestic waste: mixed municipal waste from landfills is wet, inconsistent in composition and full of contaminants, so it cannot be used as a reliable fuel without prior sorting, drying and mechanical treatment.
The situation in Kakanj is similar. Heidelberg Materials Cement BiH imported 2,284 tonnes of SRF in 2024, 4,544 tonnes in 2025 and 3,182 tonnes by early October 2026. More than 85 per cent of the SRF it uses is imported. The company likewise cites the absence of mechanical-biological waste treatment facilities in BiH as the main reason.
The combined quantities reported by these two cement plants almost exactly match the total weight of RDF/SRF recorded by the ITA under this tariff code in 2024 and 2025.
Heidelberg also openly stated that it expects to increase its use of alternative fuels. These currently replace around 15 per cent of its fossil fuels, and the company aims to raise that share to 35 per cent by 2030, partly to reduce CO₂ emissions and costs associated with the EU’s CBAM mechanism.
Cement plants are the main large-scale users of RDF/SRF in BiH.
Such plans, however, face opposition in local communities.
In Kakanj, the environmental permit for Heidelberg Materials Cement BiH is currently being renewed. The FBiH Ministry of Environment and Tourism made the company’s application available for public inspection on 6 October this year.
Activists from the informal group Za čist zrak (For Clean Air) warn about the planned increase in the use of alternative fuels and are calling for greater transparency about what is burned in the cement kiln. Particular objections concern the types of oil listed in the application for a new permit. The company says it does not currently plan to use them but has left that option open for the next five years.
Residents submitted 22 demands, including the publication of analyses of alternative fuels and consideration of other energy sources. Distrust was further heightened by an incident in August, when a large quantity of raw meal was released from a silo at the cement plant into the surrounding area, prompting the FBiH Ministry to request an inspection. The latest published findings of the FBiH inspectorate, however, state that emissions from the cement plant’s inspected stationary sources were within the prescribed limits.
This is precisely why the use of waste as fuel is not simply a question of whether a cement plant holds the required permit. It also involves checking the composition of material entering the facility, monitoring emissions from its combustion and making these data publicly available.
Both cement plants say they have strict internal controls. Lukavac Cement states that its laboratory is accredited to test RDF/SRF, with daily checks for mercury, chlorine, sulphur, calorific value and moisture, and weekly checks for heavy metals.
Nevertheless, it rejected five shipments. Four lorry loads, totalling around 100 tonnes, were returned in 2024, followed by one load of 23 tonnes in 2025, because their mercury content exceeded the plant’s internal standard. All the shipments came from Slovenia.
In 2024, Heidelberg returned one lorry load from Italy because, according to the company’s response, it contained ‘an entirely wrong shipment of waste’ rather than SRF.
The ITA, however, states that no shipments were returned or rejected at the point of import during 2024-2026, but that ten shipments were subsequently exported after analyses showed they did not meet the importers’ internal standards.
This means that the border is not the final checkpoint. In some cases, only testing at the recipient’s facility reveals that the material does not meet the requirements.
A Lorry Crosses the Border – and Oversight Passes to Other Institutions
The investigation’s most important finding concerns precisely what happens after customs clearance.
ITA BiH confirmed to us that it checks invoices, import permits, transport documents and other paperwork at the point of import, that customs officers can physically inspect goods, and that samples are taken where necessary.
But once goods are released for free circulation,routine customs supervision ends.
ITA can subsequently check the customs declaration and documentation held by the importer. However, as it states, this ‘does not mean that ITA systematically tracks whether a waste shipment has reached its final recipient and been treated at the facility specified in the documentation’.
From that point, responsibility for tracking passes to the ministries responsible for waste, inspectorates and operators.
More significantly, ITA confirmed that its information systems and those of the entity ministries are not linked in a way that enables unified electronic tracking of the same shipment from the border to final treatment.
‘There is no unified system linking the institutions that would enable automatic data exchange and continuous tracking of a waste shipment through all stages, from customs clearance to its receipt and treatment at the final facility,’ ITA states.
The FBiH Ministry of Environment and Tourism confirms almost the same thing.
MET FBIH states that establishing the path taken by a particular consignment of waste requires linking transboundary shipment documentation, proof of receipt, operators’ records and data on the recovery carried out. But the documentation available to the Ministry, it says, does not confirm the existence of a unified system to automatically track each individual shipment.
More explicitly:
‘The mere fact that a shipment has entered Bosnia and Herzegovina or has the appropriate import documentation does not, in itself, prove that it has been treated in full at the facility specified in the permit,’ MET FBIH told Gerila.
In the Republika Srpska, operators must notify the environmental inspectorate of a transboundary shipment at least three days before it starts its journey. The inspectorate then checks the paperwork covering the type and quantity of waste, the route, the vehicle and the operators’ permits. But there, too, inspectors are not required to physically inspect every delivery.
The RS Inspectorate states that it organises periodic inspections at sites where waste is received, stored and treated, based on data, previous findings and risk assessments. In around 200 inspections concerning waste management and transboundary waste movements during 2024, 2025 and 2026, it found no hazardous waste or waste types inconsistent with the permits. No laboratory analyses were conducted because, it says, none of the cases inspected raised suspicions that would require such testing.
Professor Samir Lemeš of the University of Zenica, who chairs the Management Board of Eko Forum Zenica, identifies the limited capacity for physical inspections and laboratory testing as one of the system’s weaknesses. Fully inspecting every lorry is unrealistic, he says, so much of the oversight necessarily relies on documentation. Problems arise if institutions lack sufficient capacity to verify whether a shipment’s contents match its accompanying paperwork.
‘In my view, the greatest risks are our porous borders and the lack of laboratory capacity. The law strictly defines what may be imported, but we lack the capacity to check this,’ Lemeš says.
He warns that paperwork in order and a test certificate should not be equated with independent verification of a shipment’s actual contents. As an illustration, he cites a boiler house in Zenica where, following a complaint about black smoke, inspectors could check the fuel’s test certificate but could not measure the composition of the flue gases.
‘Exactly the same situation is quite possible with RDF/SRF fuel: the certificates and documentation will be impeccable, but who knows what is lurking in it,’ Lemeš says.
A further problem, he says, is the small number of laboratories capable of testing fuel derived from waste. Citing the public register of the Institute for Accreditation of BiH, Lemeš notes that such laboratory capacity is limited. He therefore believes that any increase in transboundary waste flows would need to be accompanied by stronger independent laboratory testing.
Professor Pešević therefore considers tracking waste from entry into the country through to treatment a fundamental requirement.
‘It is not enough to know how much waste entered the country and which operator it was sent to. We need to know what type of waste was imported, in what quantity, under which permit, where it ended up and what happened to it’, she says.
While Importing Prepared Fuel, BiH Buries Its Own Waste
The paradox is most evident a few kilometres from Banja Luka, Bosnia and Herzegovina’s second-largest city.
The regional landfill in Ramići receives waste from eight cities and municipalities. According to official DEP-OT data, 142,150 tonnes of waste were disposed of there in 2025 alone, including 111,020 tonnes of municipal waste.
In August this year, the RS Ministry of Spatial Planning, Construction and Ecology, local authorities and DEP-OT concluded that the landfill’s capacity urgently needed to be expanded simply to allow waste disposal to continue. DEP-OT’s director had previously stated publicly that the existing sanitary landfill cell was full.
Igor Kalaba of the Centre for Environment believes the greatest problem is not a lack of regulations, but their implementation.
‘Generally speaking, we can say that a system exists here, but it does not work. Much of the regulatory framework is in place, but the question is how it is implemented,’ Kalaba says.
He draws particular attention to municipal waste management, where different types of waste are still mostly disposed of together, while separate collection at source is almost non-existent. During visits to the Ramići landfill, as well as illegal and temporary municipal dumps across BiH, he says they encountered municipal, construction and slaughterhouse waste mixed with industrial oils.
‘Most of it is mixed together, rarely placed in appropriate landfill cells, and regular covering with lime or soil is hardly worth discussing any more,’ Kalaba says.
In such a system, it is difficult to turn domestic waste into the resource industry needs.
Lukavac Cement uses precisely this argument to justify imports: waste from the EU arrives sorted, processed and tested, while domestic mixed municipal waste is largely unsuitable for use in a cement kiln without infrastructure to prepare it beforehand.
The problem is that, over time, this economic logic can become self-justifying. Industry imports waste because the domestic system is underdeveloped, while the system needed to turn domestic waste into a secondary raw material is not being developed quickly enough.
In assessing BiH’s application, the European Commission identified serious gaps in the data on overall capacity and future waste volumes. BiH did not provide a ten-year projection of waste generation, only a general estimate of growth without a clearly defined methodology.
In a response to this publication, a European Commission spokesperson explains that each country was assessed individually, primarily on the basis of information provided by the applicant countries, as well as other supporting information and data where available. The Commission assessed whether BiH, as a country, could demonstrate that it had the legal framework, enforcement capacity and infrastructure to manage the specific waste streams in an environmentally sound manner.
“The aim of the assessment is to verify if the request provides satisfactory evidence that the applicant country’s waste management regime meets standards necessary to ensure the environmentally sound management of the waste for which the application is being made,” the European Commission spokesperson states.
The Commission adds that the public consultation on the draft list closed on 16 October and that it is now analysing the feedback received, which will be taken into account in the final assessment.
The Delegation of the European Union to BiH stresses that BiH’s possible inclusion on the first list will not mean that the assessment is complete or that all shortcomings have been addressed. The list will be updated regularly, at least every two years, and before each update the European Commission will reassess the progress made by countries in addressing shortcomings identified in the initial assessment.
Brussels further stresses that the new regime also introduces independent audits of facilities receiving waste from the EU. Responsibility will not rest solely with the importing country: EU member states are responsible for ensuring that exported waste is managed in an environmentally sound manner and can carry out the necessary verifications if they believe that an exporter or receiving facility may not be complying with its obligations.
In other words, any decision adopted by 21 November will not provide permanent confirmation that BiH meets all the requirements but will mark the beginning of a system in which the Commission periodically checks whether the problems identified have been addressed.
This leaves BiH facing a very concrete test.
So far, BiH has demonstrated that it has companies with the permits and technology to use certain types of imported waste. The cement plants also show that they can maintain detailed internal traceability records for their own shipments, including weighing, sampling, waste transfer notes and consumption records. Lukavac, for example, states that data on every delivery are entered into a digital system, and incoming quantities are reconciled with those consumed in production.
But this is not the same as a unified national control system.
This is where the Gospić story comes back into focus.
There, the state is now spending millions of euros to identify, remove and treat waste whose movements, for years, were recorded in documents that did not reflect what was happening on the ground. In BiH, which is seeking to continue importing European waste, ITA and MET FBIH now confirm that there is no automatically linked system connecting customs records of a lorry’s entry with records of its receipt and proof that its contents were truly treated at the facility specified in the permit.
BiH expects the European Commission’s final decision by 21 November.
Until then, the paradox remains: Bosnia and Herzegovina has so far provided enough evidence to receive a provisional green light from the European Commission for some EU waste streams, but has yet to build a system that would reliably show where that waste ends up after crossing the border - who takes it over, where it is treated and what ultimately happens to it.